Skip to main content

Rules or Structure?

For the last 9 months, we've had an exchange student from Germany living at our house.  He was asked to speak in church two weeks ago (although he is not a member of our church) and he shared with the congregation that we have a lot of rules at our house, focusing on how early we get up.  This got a good laugh from the audience.

During the rest of church, we got a lot of feedback about that comment, with people wondering what all our rules are.  I was feeling quite embarrassed and maybe defensive about this and wondering if our rules really are over the top.  Certainly our children complain about them now and then.  (But what child doesn't?)
Then today, a friend from church told me how she overheard a conversation back in April where my 14-year-old daughter was asked if we have a lot of rules at our house.  My daughter responded no.  She doesn't think we have a lot of rules.  How refreshing to hear that!

As I explained to my friend, my daughter loves structure and is very good about doing what we ask her to do.  So to her, we don't have rules as much as we have structure.  Then it occurred to me that I shouldn't call them rules--that sounds arbitrary, like we're control freaks running a military school.  Instead I should call them structure and guidance and high expectations.

There are so many things we need to teach our children:  life skills like cooking and cleaning, how to take care of themselves, how to succeed in school, how to work hard, how to be disciplined, how to be on time, etc.  Additionally, we need to show them what our priorities are.  For example, family scripture study, having dinner together, having family home evening on Monday nights, going to church on Sunday and on and on. 
 


How could we accomplish that with our large family if we didn't have some structure to our day?

I had good parents but I wished for greater structure and higher expectations.  I'm giving my children what I wanted as a child.  When they're parents, maybe they'll give their children something different and that is completely fine.

So there it is.  When people say something about our rules I'm going to tell them it's not rules.  It's Structure!  Guidance!  High Expectations!

Comments

  1. DataDavidJune 14, 2015 at 11:45 AM

    I think that is a very good way to think about it. It has occasionally come up in my conversations, but when they hear that I have many siblings, people usually say - that makes a lot of sense, otherwise that big a family wouldn't work very well. I found the high expectations quite motivating and effective.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Visiting Susquehanna: The Priesthood Restoration Site

On our way home from Palmyra, we decided to go a couple of hours out of our way to visit the recently opened Priesthood Restoration Site along the Susquehanna River.  This is where we believe that Joseph Smith and Oliver Cowdery received the keys of the Aaronic Priesthood from John the Baptist which gave them the authority to baptize.  This site also has the restored Isaac and Elizabeth Hale home where Joseph and Emma lived for a year as well as the home where Joseph and Emma lived on their own. We spent a couple of hours there and I wouldn't have minded a few more minutes but we had a long way to go that night.  It's a beautiful setting, very much in rural Pennsylvania.  However, on the day we were there, cars at a racetrack nearby were detracting from the peace and quiet.  I'm guessing that's not as big of a problem on weekdays. The Hale Family was quite well-off for their day so their home was probably nicely decorated with wallpaper and carpet. ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Book Review: Out of My Mind by Sharon Draper

This is a juvenile fiction book about a young girl named Melody with severe cerebral palsy.  Her body doesn't allow her to feed herself, speak, or do much at all.  She's very intelligent with a photographic memory but she can't really communicate.  Finally, in 5th grade, she gets a "Medi-Talker" which is a computer that speaks what she types in.  Finally she has a voice. This book explores what it is like to be severely physically disabled but not mentally disabled. It seems like one of the most frustrating of all scenarios.  She is completely aware of all the cruelty (subtle and otherwise) that her classmates inflict on her because they don't really want to include her in their activities.  One of the saddest moments in the book comes when she realizes that every one of her special ed classmates is kind, where the "normal" ones are not.  Who really has the worse disability? The book was a quick read and fairly enjoyable.  Wha...
Post a Comment
Read more

Do Dots Family System

The original post was written in January of 2015. I wrote an update at the bottom of this post in March 2021. A few months ago, a friend of mine told me about something she was doing in her family to help her family function better.  Her teenage autistic son had been struggling a lot so they had been working with behavior therapists to help him and this "Do Dots Family System" had been recommended.  As she described it, I was greatly intrigued since it sounded like something I wanted to implement at my own house. I looked into it and decided to purchase it right after Thanksgiving.  Here is my review of how it has worked for us over the last six weeks or so. The basic idea of the chart is that children need to take care of their responsibilities before they get any privileges.  It strongly reinforces the concept of "Work Before Play" .  The chart helps children see in a very visual way that, until they have completed their responsibilities, they are on Le...
Post a Comment
Read more