Skip to main content

Atheists Against Atheism or Why Do We Need Organized Religion?

This week I read an interesting article, "Atheists Against Atheism" which was referencing another article, "The Turning Tide of Intellectual Atheism." The article was about how some intellectuals, historians and a journalist, who themselves do not believe in God, are recognizing the need for Christianity to maintain our society's morality.

Here are a few quotes from the article.

Niall Ferguson, agnostic and prominent historian, said, "Atheism, particularly in its militant forms, is really a very dangerous metaphysical framework for a society. I know I can't achieve religious faith, but I do think we should go to church. I don't buy the idea that evolution alone gets us to be moral...There's too much evidence that when the constraints of civilization fall away, we behave in the most savage way to one another. I'm a big believer that with the inherited wisdom of a two-millennia old religion, we've got a pretty good framework to work with."

He continued, “I’m one of these people who didn’t come to atheism by choice, and I’ve almost come out of it on the basis of historical study. The biggest disasters that we likely face are actually related to totalitarianism, because that’s the lesson of the 20th century. Pandemics killed a lot of people in the 20th century, but totalitarianism killed more.”

Another quote from the article:

For years, [Tom] Holland—an agnostic—wrote compelling histories of the ancient Greeks and Romans, but he observed that their societies were rife with casual, socially-accepted cruelty towards the weak, rape, and sexual abuse towards the massive slave class as an unquestioned way of life, and the mass extermination of enemies as a matter of course. These peoples and their ethics, Hollands writes, seemed utterly foreign to him.  It was Christianity, Holland concluded, that changed all that in a revolution so complete that even critiques of Christianity must borrow precepts from Christianity to do so.

Last night, I read an article in the Liahona written by Brad Wilcox, that talked about the need for religion. I summarize here:

"Some people think that belief in God doesn't make a difference when it comes to being a good person. "God has given us the freedom to believe in Him or not, but it's not correct to say it doesn't make a difference. Our belief in God affects how we see ourselves and how we see and treat others. Studies show that in times of trouble and crisis, believers cope much better than nonbelievers. Believers are happier and more willing to donate to charity."

When a law professor at BYU is asked by others, "What if you are wrong and God does not exist?" He answers, "I am willing to be wrong in this way if it means believing and treating others as though they are children of God...I would rather make the mistake of attributing meaning and love to a universe that is meaningless and indifferent than vice versa. And besides, I do not think we are wrong."

Many people believe in God but not organized religion. They say, I'm spiritual, not religious. Typically that means they acknowledge God's existence but do not want Him to ask anything of them.

Elder Holland has taught that spirituality might be all we need if we lived alone on a mountaintop. But we don't. When we are frustrated with the slow driver in front of us making us late to work, what we need are the standards of religion to bring the ideal of love down to the reality of the moment when someone is being unlovable.

Some people see no need for organized religion, and yet they demand organized schools, cities, stores, and hospitals. They see the benefits of going to an organized hospital. We see the same benefits in our organized church. We can care for people much more effectively when the Church is organized. Partway through the pandemic, the Church had already participated in over 1000 humanitarian aid projects. We could not have done that on our own, but we did it together because we have an organized religion.



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Our Cousin Drew

 This last week, my brother and his wife lost a very precious son, just 13 years old. He collapsed while running with a cross-country team and passed away before he could be revived. Everyone that knew Drew is broken-hearted at this loss. He was the happiest, most agreeable kid we knew. I remember him being at my house without anyone close to his age to hang out with, so he found our Duplo blocks and started building even though it is a toy that boys his age don't usually enjoy. He was so content. He didn't complain that I ever remember. His mother always called him the perfect child. He will leave a big hole in not only his immediate family but our extended family as well.  Here is a poem my aunt shared that seems fitting: Leave Taking How I would have liked to wave goodbye  and watch until you turned and smiled and disappeared on the horizon. You who taught me to dance  and let me teach you,  who laughed at my stories  and winked at me when I was sad. I can  just see you trav

Remembering Drew

 This weekend we celebrated Drew's life. On Thursday night, we gathered as an extended family and had a dinner then sat in a big circle and talked about our memories of him. I took some notes and here is what people said. Grandpa (Gary Hansen):  The last time we saw Drew was last week on the 4th. I remember all the cousins on the trampoline, bouncing up and down and playing basketball. Grandma (Susan Hansen):  I asked Drew to come over last winter to teach my Activity Day boys how to make origami stars. He was very patient in working with them even though they were pretty clueless. Eventually they all went home happily with their stars. Paula: This last winter we invited Bruce and Michelle over for dinner and we didn't have anyone his age for him to hang out with. I remember that Drew found the Duplo blocks on his own and played with them all by himself, quite cheerfully entertaining himself. I asked him if he wanted to play with a different toy--maybe something more sophistica

Drew's Funeral

Yesterday was the viewing for Drew and then today was the funeral. There were a LOT of people at the viewing. Bruce and Michelle greeted people for almost four hours yesterday and then again this morning before the funeral. Bruce said that if weren't for Drew's death, it would be the best week of his life with so much love being shown to them. Friday actually began with a family run in Drew's honor. We started at a church by the new Lindon temple and ran to Bruce and Michelle's house with breakfast following. Friday night was the viewing. There was a very nice display of all things Drew. This was one of the pictures displayed and I recognized someone I know: We stood in line and the paramedics who worked on Drew stood in line behind us so we got to talk to them. Here's a fun fact:  They cover both Orem and Vineyard but Vineyard gets a lot more 911 calls than Orem per capita. It's a younger population and they are quicker to call. They said it's hard when the